"It seems the host focused on a 'birdie party' rather than distinguishing players' skills."
Reactions across the golf community to the Inca Financial The Heaven Masters on the Korea Ladies Professional Golf Association (KLPGA) Tour, which wrapped up last weekend, have been cold. Seo Kyo-rim won with a final total of 16-under par over the three-day event. But within golf circles, sighs are emerging over the fact that the winner of a three-day KLPGA Tour event finished at a full 16-under. Critics say the careless course setup weakened the competitiveness of women's golf and also damaged the authority of professional tournaments. The gap is especially stark compared with the Mercedes-Benz 40th Korea Women's Open (4 rounds), held just one week earlier, where Kim Min-sol won at 4-under par. This is why some assess that this event failed to achieve its essential purpose of "evaluating players' skills."
According to the KLPGA on Tuesday, this season's tour has held a total of 13 events through last week. More than half of them—seven events—were played as three-round (54-hole) competitions. The fewer rounds compared with four-round events, the more sophisticated and precise the course setup must be to enhance differentiation. Because players compete over fewer holes, clear punishment and reward for shot results must be in place to produce a fair leaderboard.
So what was the "report card" of The Heaven CC in Ansan, Gyeonggi Province, where the Inca Financial The Heaven Masters was held? Looking at the numbers alone, The Heaven CC's differentiation was a birdie contest that had lost its "punishment." Seo Kyo-rim's winning score of 16-under par was more than 3 strokes below this year's average winning score for three-round events (12.6-under par). A full 59 players recorded under-par scores. That was more than double the NH Investment & Securities Ladies Championship (22), and overwhelmingly more than earlier events such as the Deokshin EPC Championship (45), the Sh Suhyup Bank MBN Women's Open (40), and the E1 Charity Open (34). The cut line was also 1-under par, lower than the over-par cut lines formed at most three-round events. The analysis is that players generally lowered their strokes too easily because of the characterless, low-difficulty course.
Golf officials agree that while players' good condition cannot be ignored, there is fundamentally a problem with the course setup. One golf official said, "Lakewood CC, where this year's Korea Women's Open was held, was criticized in the past for its easy difficulty, but through extensive improvements it transformed into a course worthy of a professional golf tournament," adding, "The reason was that it clearly distinguished the concepts of the rough, fairway, and green, ensuring solid differentiation in shot value." On the other hand, regarding The Heaven CC course, the official pointed out, "The boundary between the rough and the fairway was faint, and the grain of the rough was lying down, so there was little constraint in going for the green even when a player missed the fairway." Another official noted, "Since it was held just one week apart from the Korea Women's Open, there was almost no difference in climate conditions affecting course layout or rough growth." In fact, at the KLPGA Championship held at Lakewood CC in 2024, Lee Jung-min won with a four-day total of 23-under par, fueling controversy over difficulty. Lakewood CC, determined to make amends, strengthened its course setup by narrowing the fairway widths and growing the rough longer, and at this year's Korea Women's Open, only two players, including winner Kim Min-sol, recorded under-par scores.
The relatively short layout of 6,726 yards, operated the same for both qualifying and the main rounds, is another point that raises questions about whether the course is qualified to host a professional-level tournament. Even the longest of the 10 par-4 holes, the 2nd hole (379 yards), leaves just 140 yards to the pin after a drive of the tour average distance (239 yards). Even on the longest hole, an 8- or 9-iron is enough to attack the green, and on the rest of the par-4 holes, most ended after a driver followed by just a wedge. The charm of professional-level play—managing the course while handling all 14 clubs evenly—disappeared, reducing it to a monotonous game of who sticks their wedge shots closer. The fact that the birdie rate on the par-5 18th hole on the final day reached 46.5% starkly shows how easily this course collapsed.
A former KLPGA Tournament Committee official said, "The fact that such scores came out, even though difficulty can be adjusted through various factors such as fairway width, green speed, and green firmness, makes it look like the host set up the course focused on lowering many strokes rather than on differentiation," adding, "The cut line is usually set at over-par or even-par, so an under-par cut line means it was an easy course."
The key factor that determines a golf course's competitiveness is whether it provides "clear reward for good shots and harsh punishment for bad shots." When this balance is broken, players can attack the pin more aggressively, and as a result, a competition of low scores unfolds. The Heaven Masters winning score was 15-under par in 2024 and 13-under par in 2025, and this year it was 16-under par. If an environment where birdies pour out is repeated, there may be limits not only to the event's differentiation but also to developing the competitiveness players need on the international stage. A "birdie feast" may please fans' eyes for the moment, but it ultimately becomes a boomerang that lowers the tour's authority.
Golf tours are full of fascinating data. By subscribing to Data Golf, you can encounter the hidden stories of golf easily and enjoyably through various statistics and records. If readers have any data they are curious about or topics they would like covered, please feel free to send them by email anytime.
